Skip to content Skip to footer

Aluminium vs Steel Injection Mould: Which Material Fits Your Resin, Texture and Volume

You have two mould quotations for the same part. One proposes aluminium and costs less. The other proposes steel and takes longer. Both will mould your part. The difference shows up when the tool has run thousands of cycles or when the resin carries glass fibre.

Choosing an aluminium vs steel injection mould is a material decision. Each alloy has its own hardness and thermal conductivity, and these set the resin it accepts and the finish it keeps.

Aluminium vs steel injection mould: what changes in the material

Tooling aluminium is usually 7075 aluminium in the T651 temper, or a commercial grade made for moulds, such as QC-10. It machines several times faster than P20 tool steel, and that speed explains most of its advantage in lead time and cost.

Three properties make the difference:

  • Hardness. 7075-T651 aluminium sits around 150 HB. P20 tool steel (1.2311 or 1.2738) is supplied pre-hardened, in the order of 28 to 34 HRC. H13 steel (1.2344), hardened, works at roughly 44 to 52 HRC.
  • Thermal conductivity. Aluminium sits around 130 W/m·K and mould steels between 25 and 35 W/m·K, so aluminium conducts about four times better. The part cools sooner and the cycle shortens, above all on thick walls, although cooling channel design and wall thickness also count.
  • Thermal expansion. Aluminium expands roughly twice as much as steel (around 23 against 12 µm/m·K). With the tool hot, the clearances of slides, inserts and parting plane move more.

P20 is machined in its delivered condition, with no heat treatment afterwards. H13 is machined, hardened and ground, and those steps add lead time and explain part of its price. Aluminium needs no treatment, which is where it gains time.

Indicative tool life and maintenance for each material

The ranges below are indicative. They change with the resin, the geometry, the injection pressure and the maintenance:

  • Tooling aluminium: in the order of thousands to tens of thousands of cycles with an unfilled resin.
  • P20 steel: in the order of hundreds of thousands of cycles.
  • Hardened steel (H13 or type 420 stainless): in the order of one million cycles or more.

Aluminium wear concentrates in four places: the parting plane, the shut-offs between moving parts, the gates and the slender cores. It shows up as flash that grows slowly, and soft aluminium also gets marked by a closing impact or a trapped burr.

Repair is another difference. 7075 welds poorly, so a damaged area is almost always fixed by replacing an insert. P20 accepts build-up welding and hardened steel is repaired by laser welding. In the cooling channels, aluminium corrodes with untreated water and needs water with inhibitors. P20 can rust and sometimes receives nickel plating.

There is an intermediate solution: an aluminium cavity with steel inserts at gates, cores and shut-offs, or a steel mould base that holds aluminium inserts. It extends life where the tool suffers most and keeps a good part of the machining saving.

Which abrasive and corrosive resins rule out aluminium?

PP, PE, PS, ABS and most unfilled thermoplastics mould well in aluminium. Problems start with four families:

  • Glass and mineral fillers. Abrasive resins, such as a PA66 with 30% glass fibre or a PBT GF30, wear the tool, above all at the gates, the shut-offs and the high-flow-velocity zones. In aluminium that wear appears early, and a hardened steel with nitriding or coating resists it far better.
  • Corrosive resins. PVC and materials with halogenated flame retardants release acid gases that attack aluminium and unprotected P20. For production, hardened stainless steel (type 420, 1.2083) is the usual choice.
  • High mould temperatures. PEEK, PPS and PEI run with moulds well above 120 °C. At that temperature 7075 loses strength over time, and its expansion, double that of steel, complicates the fits.
  • High clamping and injection pressures. Aluminium has lower compressive strength than P20 steel, and the shut-off faces deform sooner with viscous resins.

A filled resin does not rule out aluminium on a very short run: with steel inserts at gates and shut-offs, the cavity lasts a few thousand cycles. Check the resin datasheet first, which states the mould temperature and the filler content.

Aluminium pays off on short runs and steel on high volumes

Machining is usually the largest line in a mould, above the material block. Because aluminium machines faster and takes no heat treatment, the tool costs less and arrives sooner. The exact difference depends on part size, number of cavities and slides.

To compare properly, count the tools needed to cover the run. Imagine an aluminium mould that yields about 20,000 parts and a project that needs 60,000. The sum is three aluminium moulds against one steel mould, and at that tool life steel usually comes out ahead. At 5,000 parts one aluminium mould is enough.

As an indicative cost reference for an unfilled resin:

  • Up to about 10,000 parts: aluminium.
  • From 10,000 to 100,000 parts: intermediate zone. Aluminium with steel inserts, or P20 steel, depending on resin, tolerances and texture.
  • Above 100,000 parts: steel, hardened if the volume or the resin demands it.

With an abrasive resin, the bands shift towards steel. With a design that may still change, they shift towards aluminium, because modifying an aluminium cavity costs less than modifying a hardened steel one.

Cooling also affects part cost. With aluminium, the conductivity of the block helps to cool, and a cooling layout copied from a steel mould can overcool. Review the thermal map before copying the channels.

Textures, polish and a DFM tip for aluminium moulds

A mirror polish and an optical finish demand hardened steel, for example a 420 stainless or an H13, because soft aluminium marks during polishing and in use. For a fine finish without optical demands, aluminium works.

Mould textures are almost always etched into steel. In aluminium they wear sooner and deep etching is less common. If the texture is part of the product, as on a visible housing, choose steel.

A frontier case: you need a fine texture on a pre-series and the volume does not justify steel. A light blast on the aluminium cavity gives a discreet, repeatable grain, and you accept that the grain will smooth out over the cycles. For a texture that must last the whole life of the product, pre-hardened P20 steel is the usual base, because it takes etching with a uniform grain.

Texture also needs draft. A common rule adds 1° to 1.5° of draft angle for every 0.025 mm of grain depth, and softer aluminium scratches sooner if the part drags.

DFM tip. If your part has a slender core, for example a deep hole of small diameter, ask for a steel insert for that core from the start of the mould design. Aluminium flexes under injection pressure and the hole ends up off-centre. Also mark the textured faces on the drawing, so the draft is calculated on them.

Frequently asked questions

How many parts can an aluminium mould make?

In the order of thousands to tens of thousands of cycles with an unfilled resin, simple geometry and correct maintenance. With steel inserts at gates and cores, the range goes up. A resin with glass fibre reduces it noticeably, to a few thousand cycles.

Can glass-filled nylon be moulded in an aluminium mould?

Yes, on very short runs and with steel inserts at gates and the fast-flow zones. The fibre wears aluminium within a few thousand cycles and flash appears early. For a larger volume, choose hardened steel with nitriding or coating, which resists the abrasion of the filler far better.

Is an aluminium mould cheaper and faster?

Yes, it usually costs less and arrives sooner, because it machines several times faster and takes no heat treatment. The exact difference depends on part size, number of cavities and complex slides. The most reliable route is to request both quotations in parallel, with the same CAD and resin.

Does an aluminium mould give worse part quality than a steel one?

At the start, part dimensions are equivalent if the mould is well made, and so is the finish, except for mirror polish and deep textures. The difference appears with use: aluminium loses stability sooner at the parting plane and on fine cores, and hardened steel keeps its polish and texture better.


Send us the CAD with the intended resin and the estimated volume, and PROTOSPAIN will tell you which mould material fits and which inserts to plan for.

We give our customers a quotation within 24 hours once they provide the project specifications and the 2D and 3D drawings.

PROTOSPAIN has been making prototypes and short runs since 2012 and holds ISO 9001:2015 certification.

Request a quote.

Leave a comment

Fulfilling
quality commitments

ABOUT PROTOSPAIN

PROTOSPAIN offers rapid prototyping, pre-series, prototyping molds and serial production mold manufacturing services, using different technologies, meeting your commitments to quality, deadlines and controlled costs.

WITH THE COLLABORATION OF:

ProtoSpain

© .2026All rights reserved.

Close